Sistemas jurídicos comparadosel trust inglés y el fideicommissum romano

  1. María Elisabet Barreiro Morales 1
  1. 1 Universidade de Vigo
    info

    Universidade de Vigo

    Vigo, España

    ROR https://ror.org/05rdf8595

Journal:
Revista jurídica da FA7: periódico científico e cultural do curso de direito da Facultade 7 de Setembro

ISSN: 1809-5836

Year of publication: 2022

Volume: 19

Issue: 1

Pages: 167-193

Type: Article

DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openOpen access editor

More publications in: Revista jurídica da FA7: periódico científico e cultural do curso de direito da Facultade 7 de Setembro

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the institution of the trust, as well as the Roman trust, for beinga key piece in the creation and evolution of the figure of Common Law. Specifi-cally, we will analyze the origins of the trust, its nature and how it works, taking the Roman trust as its basis. Later, we will carry out a small analysis about the similarities and differences be-tween both figures.Itconcludesthat the fideicommissumand the trust are institutes that serve the same purpose, but the modern trust acquired a multitude of its own peculiarities, moving away from the Roman figure, but preserving the same structure and function: the transmission of an asset, based on fides, to a third party to manage it for the benefit of others

Bibliographic References

  • ADAMS, J., RALSTON, R. The doctrine of Equity: a commentary on the law as administered by the Court of chancery, 1855.
  • AKEHURST, M., “Equity and General Principles of Law”, en The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 25, Nº 4, 1976.
  • AMES, J. B., “The origin of uses and trusts”, en Harvard Law Review, Vol. 21, Nº4, 1908.
  • BAILEY, S.J., “The Law of Property Act, 1925”, en The Cambridge Law Journal , Vol. 6, Nº 1, 1936.
  • BARROSO GARÉS, F.J.; “Los reyes británicos, La Guerra de las Dos Rosas”, en Clío: Revista de Historia, Nº 184, 2017.
  • BELLOCI, N., “La tutela della fiducia nell´epoca republicana”, en Studi Senesi, 85, 1973.
  • BERGER, A., Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law, Filadelfia, 1953, reimp. 1991.
  • BLACKHAWK, M., “Equity Outside the courts”, en Columbia Law Review, Vol. 120, Nº 8, 2020.
  • BLACKSTONE, W., Commentaries of the laws of England in Four Books, Vol. II, Oxford, 1768.
  • BOGERT, G. G., Handbook of the law of trusts, St. Paul, 1922.
  • BONFANTE, P., Corso di Diritto Romano, 2, La proprietà, 2 Vols., Roma, 1925-1928.
  • Ibid. “Forme primitive ed evoluzione della proprietà romana”, en Scritti 2, Turín, 1918.
  • BRUCE, P.J.; “The trustee and the remainderman: the trustee's duty to inform”, en Real Property, Trust and Estate Law Journal, Vol. 46, Nº 1, 2011.
  • BRUGI, B., Fedecommesso, en Digesto Italiano, XI, Torino, 1895.
  • BUCKLAND, W.W y MCNAIR, “Derecho Romano y Common Law”, Madrid, 1994.
  • BURDESE, A., “La menzione degli eredi nella fiducia cum creditore”, en Studi in onore di Siro Solazzi, Nápoles, 1948.
  • BUTERA, A., Usucapione, en Il Digesto Italiano, XXIV, Torino, 1914—1921.
  • CÁMARA, S, La fiducia sucesoria secreta, , Madrid, 1996.
  • CHECA, M., El trust angloamericano en el derecho español, Madrid, 1998.
  • CLARRY, D., “Fiduciary ownership and trusts in a comparative perspective”, en The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 63, Nº4, 2014.
  • CONVENIO DE LA HAYA de 1985 sobre la Ley Aplicable al Trust y a su Reconocimiento. En línea, https://www.hcch.net/es/instruments/conventions/full-text/?cid=59, [Fecha de consulta: 13 abril 2022].
  • Cuerpo del Derecho Civil Romano, trad. esp. I. L. GARCÍA DEL CORRAL, Digesto, tomo I y II, Barcelona, 1889 y 1892.
  • CUQ, E. “ Recherches historiques sur le testament "per æs et libram" ” ; en Nouvelle revue historique de droit français et étranger, Vol. 10, 1886.
  • DE ARESPACOCHAGA, J. , El trust, la fiducia y figuras afines, Madrid, 2000.
  • DE CASTRO, F., El Negocio Jurídico, Madrid, 1985.
  • DOMINGO AZNAR, El fideicomiso y la sustitución fideicomisaria, Madrid, 1999.
  • FLORIS MARGADANT, G. Panorama de la historia universal del Derecho, México, 2002.
  • FRATCHER, W. F., “Trust”, en International Enciclopedia of comparative Law. Vol. VI. Property and Trust, Frederick H. Lawson (Chief Editor). Tübingen-Mouton-The Hague-Paris, 1973.
  • GAYO, Instituciones, edición bilingüe, trad. esp. ABELLÁN VELASCO, M.; ARIAS BONET, J. A.; IGLESIAS-REDONDO, J.; ROSET ESTEVE, J.; Madrid, 1990.
  • GOICOECHEA, I.; “Los instrumentos de la conferencia de La Haya .de derecho internacional privado que facilitan el desarrollo de los negocios internacionales y las inversiones”, en Revista da Secretaria do Tribunal Permanente de Revisão, Vol. 3, Nº 5, 2015.
  • GRETTON, G.L., “Trusts without Equity”, en The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 49, Nº 3, 2000.
  • HAIGH, P.A., The Military Campaigns of the Wars of the Roses, 1995.
  • HANBURY, H. G.; MARTIN, E. M., Modern Equity, London, 2015.
  • HARPUM, C., BRIDGE, S. & DIXON, M., Megarry & Wade: The Law of Real Property, 2008.
  • HAYTON, D. J., The Law of Trusts (Fundamental Principles of Law), London, 1998.
  • HELMHOLZ, R. H., “The Early Enforcement of Use”, en Columbia Law Rewiew, 1979.
  • HEPBURN, S. “Principles of Equity and Trusts”, en Annandale, N.S.W.: The Federation Press, 2020.
  • HOLDSWORTH, W., “The Political Causes which shaped the Statute of Uses”, en Harvard Law Review, Vol. 26, Nº 2, Harvard, 1912.
  • Ibid. A History of English Law, London, 1927.
  • IVES, E.W., “The Genesis of the Statute of Uses”, en The English Historical Review, Oxford, 1967.
  • JENKS, E., “El Derecho Inglés”, Madrid, 1930.
  • Ibid. “The prerogative writs in English Law”, en Yale Law Journal, Vol. 32, Nº 6, 1923.
  • KEETON, G. W.; SHERIDAN, L. A., The Law of Trusts, London, 1993.
  • LEPAULLE, P. , “Civil Law Substitutes for Trust” en The Yale Law Journal , Vol. 36, Nº 8, 1927.
  • LEPAULLE, P. “La naturaleza del trust”, trad. Español MACEDO, P; en Revista General de Derecho y Jurisprudencia, Tomo 3, 1932.
  • Ibid. “Trusts and the Civil Law”, en Journal of Comparative Legislation and International Law, 1933, Vol. 15, Nº 1, 1933.
  • LOZANO CORBI, E.A.; “Origen de la propiedad romana y de sus limitaciones”, en Proyecto Social: Revista de Relaciones Laborales, Nº 2, 1994.
  • MACNAIR, M., “Equity and Conscience”, en Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 27, Nº. 4, 2007.
  • MAITLAND, F. W., Equity also the forms of action of Common Law; two courses of lectures, Cambridge, 1910.
  • MARSH, A.H., History of the Court of Chancery and of the rise and development of the doctrines of Equity, 1890.
  • MARTÍN SANTIESTEBAN, S., “El family trust. Reflexiones acerca de una posible regulación en derecho español”, en Personalidades jurídicas difusas y artificiales, Nº 4, 2019.
  • Ibid. El instituto del “trust” en los sistemas legales continentales y su compatibilidad con los principios de “civil law”, Navarra, 2005.
  • Ibid . “La figura del trust en los Estados Unidos de América”, Revista para el análisis del derecho, 2008.
  • MEADWAY, S., “Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 2009”, en Trusts & Trustees, Vol. 16, Issue 4, 2010.
  • MEGARY, R., “The Statute of Uses and the Power to Devise”, en Cambridge Law Journal, Cambridge, Vol. 7, Issue 3, 1941.
  • MENDOZA POPOCA, O. A., “Fideicomiso romano y trust anglosajón. La semejanza de su desarrollo”, en Revista de la Facultad de Derecho de México, Vol. 67, Nº 268, 2017.
  • MURPHY, W.T., FLESSAS, T., ROBERTS, S., Understanding Property Law, London, 2003.
  • OOESTERHOFF, A.H., “The Law of Mortmain: An Historical and Comparative Review”, en The University of Toronto Law Journal, Vol. 27, Nº 3, 1977.
  • ORTH, J.V.; “Wills act formalities: How much compliance is enough?”, en Real Property, Trust and Estate Law Journal, Vol. 43, Nº 1, 2008
  • POUND, R.; “The Decadence of Equity”, en Columbia Law Review, Vol. 5, Nº 1, 1905.
  • SCOTT, A. W. and FRATCHER, W. F., The Law of Trust, Vol. I, Boston – Toronto, 1987.
  • SCOTT, A. W., “The trust as an instrument of law reform”, en Yale Law Journal, Vol. XXXI, nº 5 1922.
  • SOLAZZI, S., Istituzioni di Diritto Romano, Tomo II, Roma, 2002.
  • STONE, H.F.; “The Nature of the Rights of the "Cestui Que Trust"” en Columbia Law Review, Vol. 17, Nº 6, 1917.
  • STONE, O.M., “Contracts to Make Wills, and the Scope of Section 24, Wills Act, 1837”, en The Modern Law Review, Vol. 20, Nº5, 1957.
  • TAZÓN CUBILLAS, A., “Aproximación al concepto de fideicomiso tácito en el Derecho Romano”, en Anuario da Facultade de Dereito da Universidade da Coruña, Nº 13, 2009.
  • TERRAZAS PONCE, J.D., “Orígenes y cuadro histórico del fideicomiso”, en Revista Chilena de Derecho, 1998.
  • TOMAS, G., and HUDSON, A., The Law of Trusts, 2004.
  • TUCKER, P., “The Early History of the Court of Chancery: A Comparative Study", en English Historical Review, Oxford, 2000.
  • TURNER, C.W., “Uses before the Statute of Uses” en Virginia Law Review, Virginia, 1916.
  • VAN RHEE, C.H., “Trusts, trust-like Concepts and Ius Commune”, en European Review of Private Law, 3/2000.
  • VILCA POZO, M., “El contrato fideicomiso: una visión histórica de sus antecedentes y evolución normativa”, en Revista Direitos Fundamentais & Democracia, Nº 23, 2018.
  • VIRGÓS SORIANO, M., El trust y el derecho español, Madrid, 2006.
  • VOLTERRA, E., Instituciones de Derecho Privado Romano, Madrid, 1986.
  • WEBB, C., AKKOUH, T., Trusts Law, Palgrave, 2008.
  • WEICHTMAN, H., “Supreme Court of Judicature. Court of Appeal. The Queen v. Orton”, en The American Law Register, Vol. 28, Nº 10, 1880.
  • WHALEY, M.S., “Common Law Writs”, en South Carolina Law Review, Vol. 11, Issue 5, 1959.
  • WHEELER COOK, W., “The Powers of Courts of Equity. I. "In Rem" and "In Personam", en Columbia Law Review, Vol. 15, Nº 1, 1915.
  • WOLFF, J., Trust, Fiducia and Fiduziarische Treuhand. Historich-rechtsvergleichende Untersuchung mit einer Darstellung des Trust in Schottland sowi des römischen und österreichischen Fideikommiss. Peter Lang AG, Frankfurt am Main, Berlin, Bern, Bruxells, New York, Oxford, Wien, 2005.
  • ZARTALOUDIS, T., “Theories of origin as to the progenitor of the trust”, en Divus Thomas, Vol. 115, Nº 2, 2012.
Data source: Dialnet