Análisis del efecto de un modelo de evaluación recíproca sobre el aprendizaje de los deportes de equipo en el contexto escolar

  1. Figueiredo, L. M.
  2. Lago Peñas, Carlos
  3. Fernández Villarino, María Ángeles
Journal:
European Journal of Human Movement

ISSN: 0214-0071,  2386-4095

Year of publication: 2008

Issue: 21

Pages: 99-117

Type: Article

DIALNET GOOGLE SCHOLAR lock_openDialnet editor

More publications in: European Journal of Human Movement

Abstract

Evaluating students´ performance in team sports at school is a problem many investigators have faced. Our study has aimed to build, to apply and to verify the effectiveness, in students´ learning, an adaptation of the Assessment Process of Performance in team sports (GPAI), created by Oslin, Mitchell and Griffin (1998) to be used in the Physical Education subject at school. The sample consisted of 48 pupils divides into an experimental group (24 pupils) and a control group (24 pupils) belonging to the second year of the Enseñanza Secundaria Obligatoria (ESO). The dependent variable was the performance obtained by pupils in their declarative knowledge, general game performance decision making and skill execution. As assessment instruments were used the written questionnaire, to evaluate pupils´ declarative knowledge and the observation of pupils´ performance in a game situation by a team of three experts to check the levels of qualify in decision making and the skill execution. Analysing the information differences were found in the results of an experimental group and a control group. The experimental group of pupils has been submitted to an observation program of their peer´ performance in game. We can verify statistically significant differences in the results of both groups in the following aspects: declarative knowledge, general game performance decision making and skill execution. These results achieved in the final evaluation were better in the experimental group.

Bibliographic References

  • ANGUERA, M.T. (1983). Manual de prácticas de observación. México: Trillas.
  • ANGUERA, M.T. (1991). Metodología observacional en la investigación psicológica. Barcelona: P.P.U.
  • BLÁZQUEZ, D. (1990). Evaluar en Educación Física. Barcelona: INDE.
  • BUNKER, D. Y THORPE, A. (1983). A model for the teaching of games in secondary schooles. Bulletin of physical education, 19, 5-9.
  • CONTRERAS, O. (1998). Didáctica de la Educación Física. Un enfoque constructivista. Barcelona: INDE:
  • DÍAZ, J. (2005). La evaluación formativa como instrumento de aprendizaje en educación física. Barcelona: INDE.
  • ESEP (2005). New didactics in teaching ganes with applications to basketball and team handball. On ESEP (CD-Rom). Macromedia. Inc.
  • FRENCH, K. Y THOMAS, G. (1987). The relation of knowledge development to children’s basketeball performance. Journal of sport psychology (9), 15 – 32.
  • FRENCH, K. E., NEVETT, M. E., SPURGEON, J. H., GRAHAM, K. C., RINK, J. E. Y MCPHERSON, S. L. (1996). Knowledge representation and problem solution in expert and novice youth baseball players. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Spor, 67(4), 386-395.
  • FRENCH, K., WERNER, P., TAYLOR, K., HUSSEY, K. Y JONES, J. (1996). The Effects of a 6 – Week Unit of Tactical, Skill, or Combined Tactical and Skill Instruction on Badminton Performance of NinthGrade Students. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 15, 439-463.
  • GARGANTA, J. (1998). Analisar o jogo nos desportos colectivos. Uma preocupação comum ao treinador e ao investigador. Horizonte (83): 7- 14.
  • GÓMEZ, P. Y PERCKZYK, J. (2001). El rol del alumno observador en educación física: un marco de referencia para la enseñanza y la coevaluación. Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportiva (www.efdeportes.com/, Año 7, N. 43.
  • GRÉHAIGNE, J. GODBOUT, P. Y BOUTHIER, D. (1997). Performance assessment in team sports. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 16, 500-516..
  • GRÉHAIGNE, J. Y GODBOUT, P. (1998). Formative Assessment in Team Sport in a tactical Approach Context, In Journal of Physical Education Recreation and Dance, 69(1) 46- 51.
  • GREHAIGNE, J. Y GODBOUT, P. (1999). La prise de décision de l’éleve en sport collectif. In actes du colloque international – Qu’apprennent les élèves en faisant des activités physiques et sportives ? Editores Gréhaigne, J. Mahut, N. y Marchal, D. L’université de Franch-comté.
  • GREHAIGNE, J., GODBOUT, P. Y BOUTHIER, D. (2001). The teaching and learning of decision making in team sports. Quest. 53, 59-76.
  • GRIFFIN, L., OSLIN, J. Y MITCHELL, S. (1995) : An analysis of two instructional approaches to teaching net games. Research quarterly for exercise and sport, 66 supplement, A-64.
  • HERNÁNDEZ, J.L..Y VELÁZQUEZ, R. (2004). La evaluación en educación física. Investigación y práctica en el ámbito escolar. Barcelona: Graó.
  • LÓPEZ, V. (2004). La participación del alumnado en los procesos evaluativos. La autoevaluación y la evaluación compartida en Educación Física. En Didáctica de la Educación Física. Una perspectiva crítica y transversal. Madrid: Biblioteca Nueva.
  • MCPHERSON, S. Y FRENCH, K. (1991). Changes in cognitive strategies and motor skills in tennis. Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology (13), 26-41.
  • MÉARD, J.A. (1987): La co-evaluación en Educación Física y Deportiva, EPS, 207, .41-44.
  • MÉNDEZ, A. (1998). La observación en vivo del rendimiento deportivo. Un instrumento de análisis en iniciación al baloncesto. Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportiva (www.efdeportes.com/, Año 3, N. 12.
  • MÉNDEZ, A. (1999). Modelos de enseñanza deportiva. Análisis de dos décadas de investigación. Lecturas: Educación Física y Deportiva (www.efdeportes.com/, Año 4, N. 13
  • MITCHELL, S., GRIFFIN L. Y OSLIN, J. (1995). An análisis of two instructional approaches to teaching invasion games. Research quarterly for exercise and sport, 66 supplement, A-65.
  • MITCHELL, S. Y OSLIN, J. (1999). Assessment series K-12 physical education series: Assessmnet in games teaching. Reston, VA: Nacional Association of sport and Physical Education.
  • MORTAGUA, L. (2007). A avaliação do rendimento individual em desportos de invasão na Educação Física. A participação dos alunos do ensino básico numa perspectiva de coavaliação. Tese de Doutoramento, Universidade de Vigo.
  • MUSCH, E, Y MERTENS, B. (1991). L´Enseignement des sports collectifs: une conception elaboreé a L´ISEP de l´Université de Grand. Revue de l´Education Physique, 31(1), 7-20.
  • NADEAU, L. (2001). La validation d´un outil de mesure de la performance an jockey sur glace en situation réelle de match. Thése presenteé a la Faculté des études supérieures de l´Université Lval pou l´obtention du grade de Philosophia e Docotor. Départament d´education physique. Faculté de Sciences de L´Education. Université Laval. Quebec.
  • NEVETT, M., ROVEGNO, I., BABIARZ, M. Y MCCAUGHTRY, N. (2001). Changes in Basic tactic and motor skills in an invasión-type game alter a 12-lesson unit of instruction. Journal of teaching in physical education. (20), 352 – 369.
  • OSLIN, J. (2005). The role of assessment in teaching games for understanding. In Teaching Games for understanding. 125-135.
  • OSLIN, J., MITCHELL, S. Y GRIFFIN, L. (1998). The Game Performance Assessment Instrument (GPAI): Development and Preliminary Validation. In Journal of Teaching in Physical Education. 17, 231-243.
  • PRUDENTE, J.; GARGANTA, J, Y ANGUERA, M.T. (2004). Desenho e validaçao de un sistema de observaçao no Andebol. En Revista portuguesa de Ciencias do Desporto, Vol. 4, N.3, 49-65.
  • RICHARD, J. (1998). Le mesure et l´evaluation de la performance en jeux et sports collectifs : la participation des éléves du primaire dans une perspective d´évaluation authentique. Tesis Doctoral. Université de Laval, Quebec, Canadá.
  • RICHARD, J. Y GRIFFIN, L. (2003). Authentic Assessment in Games Education: An Introduction to Team Sport Assessment Procedure and the Game Performance Assessment Instrument. In Physical Education and Sport. Joy Butler, Linda Griffin, Ben Lombard y Richard Nastasi (eds.). USA: AAHPERD Publications, pp. 155-166.
  • RICHARD, J., GODBOUT, P. Y GRÉHAIGNE, J. (2000). Students’ Precision and interobserver reliability of performance assessmnet in team sports. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport. 71 (1), 85-91.
  • RICHARD, J., GODBOUT, P., TOUSIGNAT, M. Y GRÉHAIGNE, J. (1999). L’expérimentation d’une stratégie d’évaluation formative en sports collectifs dans un contexte d’enseignement par/pour la compréhension. In J. F. Gréhaigne, N. Mahut e D. Marchal (Eds.) International AIESEP Congress. Besançon. France.IUFM de Franche Comité.
  • RICARDO, V. (2005). Novas estratégias de ensino para os jogos desportivos. Estudo experimental na modalidade de basquetebol em alunos do 9º ano de escolaridade. Dissertação de Mestrado. FCDEF-UP. Porto.
  • RINK, J. (1993). Teacher education – A focus on action. Quest, 45, 308-320.
  • ROVEGNO, I., NEVETT, M. Y BABIARZ, M. (2001). Learning and teaching invasion-game in 4th grade: Introduction and theoretical perspective. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education. 20(4), 341-351.
  • ROVEGNO, I., NEVETT, M., BRROCK, S. Y BABIARZ, M. (2001). Teaching and learning basic invasion-game tactics in 4th grade: A descriptive study from situated and constainnts theoretical perspective. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education. 20(4), 370-388.
  • SIEDENTOP, D. (1987). Dialogue or exorcism? A rejonde to Schempp. Journal of Teaching in Physical Education, 6, 373-376.
  • TURNER, A. Y MARTINEK, T. (1995). Teaching for understanding: a Model for Improving Decision Making During Game Play. Quest. 47(1), 44-63.
  • TURNER, A. Y MARTINEK, T. (1999). An investigation in to teaching games for understanding: effects on skill, knowledge, and game play. Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 70(3), 286-296.
  • WERNER, P., BUNKER, D. Y THORPE, R. (1996). Teaching games for understanding: Evolution of a model. Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and dance. 67 (1), 28-33.
Data source: Dialnet